# Windfarms Don’t Destroy Bird Populations

- Link: https://greenlivingguy.com/2012/04/windfarms-dont-destroy-bird-populations/
- Published: 2012-04-17T11:50:17-04:00
- Author: greenlivingguy

A large majority of birds can co-exist or thrive with operating windfarms, but some
species are harmed during construction

The new study goes against widespread allegations by critics of windfarms that clusters
of turbines routinely cause serious damage to wild birds.

A major new study has quashed fears that onshore windfarms are causing long-term
damage to bird populations, but found new evidence that some species are harmed 
when windfarms are built.

The study by conservationists into the impacts on 10 of the key species of British
upland bird, including several suffering serious population declines, concluded 
that a large majority of species can co-exist or thrive with windfarms once they
are operating.

But the study, the largest carried out in the UK into the impact of onshore windfarms
on bird life, also found strong evidence that some species suffered serious harm
while windfarms are being built.

“It shows that there can be serious species-level impacts in the construction phase,
so construction in the right place is absolutely key. But what it hasn’t shown is
that windfarms are ‘bird blenders’. There is no impact from the turning of the blades,”
said Martin Harper, the RSPB’s UK conservation director.

The study, which is published in the Journal of Applied Ecology, was carried out
jointly by four naturalists and ornithologists from the RSPB, Scottish Natural Heritage
and the British Trust for Ornithology (BTO). It goes against widespread allegations
by critics of windfarms that clusters of turbines routinely cause serious damage
to wild birds, through collision with the revolving blades, noise and visual disturbance.

James Pearce-Higgins, the lead author and principal ecologist with the BTO, said:“
It was a bit of a surprise that the impact on windfarms seemed to be happening during
construction rather than operation.”

“It means we should look at ways in which these negative impacts can be minimised.
The next step will be to find out whether those steps are effective,” he said.

The most alarming findings were for the curlew, Britain’s largest wader, whose numbers
fell 40% in a radius of up to 800m from the site during construction at the 18 windfarms
in northern England and Scotland involved in the study. Curlew numbers remained “
significantly lower” after the windfarms began operating, after they abandoned nesting
sites. Snipe numbers also failed to recover, falling by 53% within 400m of the study
sites. Red grouse numbers also fell but rose again after construction finished.

Ornithologists are becoming increasingly anxious about the UK’s overall curlew numbers;
they have fallen sharply by about half, since 1995, and the UK is host to one-third
of Europe’s entire curlew population. The species is now on the amber list of threatened
bird species.

The study’s authors said these findings were balanced out by the discovery that 
two species, the skylark and stonechat – which prefer open, broken and short vegetation–
flourished during the building phase. The other species, such as meadow pipit, golden
plover, wheatear, whinchat, dunlin and lapwings, showed either no change or less
certain reactions. There was evidence that meadow pipits prospered on windfarm sites
while golden plover numbers fell, but the authors said further work was needed to
show a link to the windfarm development.

The study’s authors warned that their findings presented strong evidence that new
developments should be carefully sited to minimise impacts on birds.

Pearce-Higgins said one caveat was that more long-term data was needed to ensure
their findings were robust: some of the windfarms being studied had only been operating
for three years.

There have been notorious, historic, cases of windfarms in other countries affecting
local bird populations. Studies in the UK had found evidence that birds of prey 
in particular avoided windfarms, reducing the available food supplies and habitat.
Bats can also be affected.

The RSPB was very critical of a decision by the Scottish government last week to
approve the Viking windfarm on Shetland, despite clear evidence that its 103 turbines
would harm nesting grounds and habitat for whimbrel and red-throated divers.

Sources: [Severin Carrell, Scotland correspondent, guardian.co.uk](https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/apr/12/windfarms-damage-bird-populations),
Thursday 12 April 2012 08.20 EDT

ET List, [http://www.electrifyingtimes.com](http://www.electrifyingtimes.com)

To view ET List message archive go to:
 [http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ETList/messages](https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/ETList/conversations/messages)

**More on Green Living From The Green Living Guy**

**The Suburbs, Unplugged (NYPA/THINK Clean Commute Program)- NY Times **

GE Technology and How It Will Help Integrate Electric Vehicles

Green Students Bring New Energy Ideas Northwest Style

Green Guru Guides Do It Yourself Energy Audits: Simple Solutions to Reduce Your 
Utility Bill and Carbon Footprint
