# Supreme Court Called on to Reject Discrimination against Rooftop Solar

- Link: https://greenlivingguy.com/2018/02/supreme-court-called-on-to-reject-discrimination-against-rooftop-solar/
- Published: 2018-02-21T22:00:54-05:00
- Author: greenlivingguy

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Six climate and energy-conservation groups took legal action 
in the [Supreme Court](https://greenlivingguy.com/2011/06/supreme-court-reaffirms-epa-role-addressing-global-warming-pollution/).
The group will challenge an Arizona power-utility company seeking legal immunity
to discriminate against rooftop-solar customers.

The Salt River Project is a public power utility in Arizona. In 2015, they raised
electricity rates for rooftop-solar customers by 60 percent. In response the rooftop-
solar company, SolarCity alleged in an antitrust lawsuit that the utility’s action
unlawfully stamps out competition. The utility argued that public power companies
are shielded from antitrust laws, rather than defending the merits of their discriminatory
behavior in court. The case is now being heard by the Supreme Court.

### Today’s amicus brief asserts that the Salt River Project should not be immune from antitrust liability. The groups’ filing also states that the power utility’s obstruction of rooftop-solar deployment undermines the very public-interest objectives that utility monopolies were created to serve.

“The Salt River Project and other utilities shouldn’t be allowed to overcharge and
discriminate against homeowners who embrace clean solar energy,” said Jean Su, associate
conservation director at the Center for Biological Diversity. “In our era of runaway
climate change, it’s critical for the Supreme Court to stop these outdated monopolies
from abusing the law and trying to strangle renewable-energy development.”

“The Salt River power company is attempting to stifle renewable energy for its own
financial gain, but punishing homeowners for going solar is shortsighted and reckless,”
said Wenonah Hauter, executive director of Food & Water Watch. “Too many elected
officials receive contributions from the fossil fuel companies to look the other
way. It’s critical that the courts weigh in and put a stop to these illegal and 
immoral practices. Solar energy is critical for the future of this planet. We must
transition off of fossil fuels, starting now.”

“We are deeply concerned about the coordinated efforts of the Salt River Project
and other monopoly utilities to stifle the growth of solar energy,” said Jim Warren,
executive director of NC WARN. “Distributed solar, combined with battery storage,
is a path that can help slow the climate crisis. Continuing our status quo of big
utility construction of unneeded power plants is disastrous.”

The [case for preserving an electric](https://greenlivingguy.com/2005/11/the-case-for-electric-vehicles-now/)
utility’s monopoly over electricity generation died with federally induced wholesale
competition in the late 1970s and with the recent advent of customer-owned and cost-
effective rooftop solar,” said John Farrell, director of the Energy Democracy Initiative
at the Institute for Local Self-Reliance. “The Supreme Court should permanently 
bury it in 2018.”

“The pattern of anticompetitive behavior utilities and corporations are pursuing
to stop solar from growing is both cynical and dangerous,” said Naomi Ages, acting
director of Greenpeace USA’s climate and energy campaign. “We need to transition
to 100 percent renewable energy as quickly and equitably as possible in order to
ensure we avoid the worst effects of climate change. The Supreme Court cannot allow
these discriminatory business practices that continue to harm our climate and our
communities.”

“Corporate bullies should not be allowed to use illegal tactics to block the development
of clean energy,” said Marcie Keever, legal director at Friends of the Earth. “These
old-school energy companies are afraid of a fair and level playing field and are
trying to prevent innovation. To create an equitable energy future based on renewable
sources, we must oppose the illegal protections private companies use to defend 
fossil fuels. We urgently need to transition to [cleaner sources of power for the planet](https://greenlivingguy.com/2026/06/circular-ev-battery-recycling-for-a-cleaner-planet/)
and everyone who lives on it.”

###

Friends of the Earth fights to create a more healthy and just world. Our current
campaigns focus on promoting clean energy and solutions to climate change. Moreover,
ensuring the food we eat and products we use are safe and sustainable. Not to mention
protecting marine ecosystems and the people who live and work near them.
 [https://foe.org/news/supreme-court-called-reject-discrimination-rooftop-solar/](https://foe.org/news/supreme-court-called-reject-discrimination-rooftop-solar/)

Center for Biological Diversity, Food & Water Watch, Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace
USA, Institute for Self-Reliance, NC WARN, Inc.
